http://web.pdx.edu/~rueterj/courses/esr102-201001/lecture7.html

Lecture 7: Impact of Agriculture

February 18, 2010

  1. at end quiz
  2. I=PAT and Importance of agriculture
  3. energy and society
  4. humans harnessed ecology for agriculture
  5. types of farming - uses of capital and labor
  6. the Green Revolution
  7. the food people choose to eat has environmental impact
  8. scenarios for the future need to deal with global food production
  9. transition to sustainable and secure food
  10. food vs. fuel
  11. high touch food production examples

 

 

1. return at end of lecture and go over the quiz

 

 

2. I=PAT equation

agriculture has a big impact

water - largest user

energy - 17% of all commercial energy in the US

emissions - 20% of CO2 emissions, 55% of methane

 

 

3. energy and society

progression around agriculture helped structure society

link

 

 

4. Humans harnessed ecosystems for agriculture

primary and secondary succession

traditional view of ecosystem succession

 

 

5. Types of agriculture

trade-offs between: machine capital, human labor, energy, chemical costs, and land

low-technology farming

  • smaller
  • less productive
  • subsistence or local market only

intensive agriculture

  • high human labor
  • maybe fertilizer costs
  • low to none traction
  • small land use

industrial agriculture

  • low human labor
  • high traction and fertilizer costs
  • and machinery
  • can use lower grade soil but needs lots of it

another description (Pollan)

  • industrial
  • industrial organic
  • artisan - smaller scale

 

 

6. "Green Revolution"

Brought together:

  • plant genetics
    • higher yield grains and rice
    • less stalk more grain
    • hardier for harvesting
  • availability of irrigation
    • higher water demand
  • use of petrochemicals
    • fertilizers (N and P)
    • herbicides and pesticides
    • traction

benefits:

  • meeting food demand for many developing countries avoiding famines
  • food security
  • excess food for income

disadvantages:

  • moving toward fewer varieties - depleting natural range of crops
  • dependence on irrigation, more severe impact when there is a drought
  • dependence on energy subsidies

 

 

indirect effects of these process

water consumption

lake eutrophication from runoff - case study

 

 

7. impacts from food choices

not in the food itself but in the embodied or life-cycle energy

people may consume more goods, but bulk food consumption stays the same

however, different foods may require more or less water or energy

  • examples from last week on the embedded water in foods (water embedded in food)
  • energy in foods (about 10 * as much as nutritional)
    • 68 kcal of fossil fuel energy to make 1 kcal worth of pork
    • 35 kcal of fossil fuel energy to make 1 kcal worth of beef
    • references - link
    • high and low life cycle energy input for food can result in 5 fold difference
    • animal products range over about 4 fold range, so the particular recommendation for saving energy needs to take that into account
    • clams 27 MJ per portion, down to fresh cooked local cow at 3.2 MJ per portion
    • 27 MJ = 6480 kCal of embodied or life-cycle energy
    • link
  • Ecotrust calculations show that air transported fresh salmon costs 57 times more CO2 than frozen

 

8. scenarios for the future

Millenium Ecosytem Assessment

4 scenarios

powerpoint MEA - from lab

 

 

9. transition to a sustainable and secure food system

sustainable food production

details next lecture

food security

  • amount of food
  • types of food available vs. nutrition
  • economics
    • fuel
    • fertilizer
    • land ownership issues
  • risks in the distribution system
  • sensitivity to disruption from climate

 

 

10. Food vs. Fuel controversy

bio-fuels are competing with food production

  • water
  • land

environmental choice, economic incentives and policies play a big role

  • tax credits
  • carbon incentives
  • rules that require proportion of fuel to be biodiesel of ethanol

impact on land use and biodiversity

 

11. High touch food production

Examples to consider for next lecture:

Polyface Farms in NC - mentioned in Michael Pollan's book

Zena Farms here in Willamette Valley - summer program

Tryon Creek community

Portland Urban Growth Bounty

WWOOF

example in Spain