UNST 111A: Faith and Reason
Portland State University
Fall 2009
(c) John S. Ott

Reading Guide:
Hildegard of Bingen, Holistic Healing, trans. M. Pawlik, et al., pp. 1-17, 61-69, 179-192




Introductory notes and background

Hildegard was born in 1098 as the youngest of 10 children, to Hildebert and Mechtild of Bermersheim in the Rhineland-Hesse region of Germany.  She was dedicated to a religious life by her parents from her infancy and began religious instruction and rudimentary schooling around the age of eight under the guidance of a devout recluse named Jutta.  From an equally tender age--from age 3, she would later say--Hildegard routinely experienced waking visions, perhaps brought on by powerful migraine headaches that would incapacitate her for long periods of time.  In part because of these experiences, she would eventually, if reluctantly, come to see herself as a visionary.  As a teenager, she took the veil and become a nun, and on Jutta's death Hildegard took over the direction of the small convent, serving as abbess from 1136.  Five years later, during one of her visions, she heard herself commanded to write down everything she saw and heard.  After considerable delay she finally obeyed, and began work on the Scivias, or Three Books of Visions and Revelations.  The pope read parts of this treatise, ultimately approving its content and Hildegard's visions as authentic and legitimate.  Although apparently never formally educated beyond what was customary for girls in a monastic cloister, Hildegard was a person of exceptional intellectual curiosity and talent.  She wrote, in addition to collection of visions, medical works, poems, musical compositions, a wide range of learned treatises, sermons, and letters, as well as an unfinished autobiography.  In 1150, she and her community of nuns moved to Bingen, where she continued to serve as abbess until her death.  During this time she was an active correspondent and sometime critic of popes, kings, queens, cardinals, other religious leaders, abbots, and abbesses.  Approximately 300 of her letters survive.  She traveled extensively in western German, and was permitted to preach sermons on a range of subjects, a highly unusual distinction for a woman at this time.  Although sometimes regarded as a saint, Hildegard was never canonized.  She died in 1179.

Between 1151 and 1158, thus after her move to Bingen, Hildegard composed her Holistic Healing (in Latin, known as the Causae et curae, or Causes and Cures), which describes the natural world, human physiology and psychology, illnesses, and treatments.  Hildegard’s discussion, which may seem a bit disconnected at times, will be more comprehensible if you bear in mind that she viewed all created matter as being composed of admixtures, in different proportions, of physical elements and bodily humors, and subject to a variety of external forces.  The bodily humors or four fluids had been identified by earlier Greek medical thinkers and were reiterated by the physician Galen (died about 200 CE), the great summarizer of Greek medical knowledge.  The humors, and their corresponding elements, were:

phlegm or mucus (phlegmatic) / water
blood (sanguine) / air
black bile (melancoly) / earth
yellow bile or gall (choleric) / fire

We know that Hildegard practiced medical healing as well as wrote about it.  She was frequently sought out for medical advice as well.  Her achievements in the field are all the more impressive given that the practice of medicine itself was gradually diminishing in monasteries, and medical training from the thirteenth century on was generally secured in universities.  Holistic Healing survived the Middle Ages in a single manuscript, which was not "discovered" until 1859, in Copenhagen, Denmark.



Questions and exercises

(1) As you read, try to arrange by subject the topical headings of the first 17 assigned pages.  Why does Hildegard begin her treatise on holistic healing with an overview of Creation and Lucifer’s fall?

(2) What sort of images and metaphors does Hildegard use to explain and discuss natural phenomena, human biological functions, and the composition of the universe?

(3)  What is the logic behind her descriptions of the different personality types? (that is, melancholics, phlegmatics, etc.)

(4) How can we understand or explain the sorts of cures she prescribes for routine and unusual illnesses?  Are there common characteristics to her prescriptions?