world-views-table-2.html

World Views - Several Descriptions

link from world-views-table.html

Cornucopian / Accomodating / Comunalist / Deep Ecologist

  technology sustainability other
Cornucopian optimistic technologist very weak individual and property rights
Accommodating - industrial ecology use efficient technologies and market incentives all capital is interconvertable, weak sustainability

equity for all

instrumental value in nature, utilitarianism

Communalist - committed environmentalist preserve resources strong sustainability

green economy

collective interests take precedence over individual human interests

 

Deep ecology

preservationist

severely limit resource take

very strong sustainability

broader definition of rights (animal, plant and earth system)

 

 

Turner et al. 1993

 

Immaterialist / Pessimist / Technocrat / Carpe diem / Optimist

see pdf for table

 

van den Bergh, Jeroen C. J. M. 1997. An assessment of the growth debate: A comparison of perspectives

 

Individualist / Egalitarian / Hierarchist

The Cultural Theory of risk, often referred to simply as Cultural Theory (with capital letters; not to be confused with culture theory), consists of a conceptual framework and an associated body of empirical studies that seek to explain societal conflict over risk (Wikipedia) World views would be self-reinforcing beliefs and actions.

characterisitc Hierarchist Egalitarian Individualist
myth of nature tolerant within limits fragile robust
myth of human sinful good and malleable self-seeking
ethical attitude partnership ecocentrism anthropocentrism
management style control prevention adaptation
salient value stability equity and equality growth
attitude towards risk risk-accepting risk-averse risk-seeking

 

 

van Asselt, M. B. A., and Jan Rotmans (1996). "Uncertainty in perspective." Global Environmental Change 6(2): 121-157.

van Asselt, M. B. A., and Jan Rotmans (2002). "Uncertainty in integrated assessment modelleing: from positivism to pluralism." Climate Change 54: 75-105.