objects/new-type-of-science.html

New Type of Science

link to two types of science

A. Previous or traditional science

used in biology and chemistry

hypothesis testing cycle (information, hypothesized explanation, test, modify, repeat)

value free

high threshold for claims (such as a 95% confidence interval for data) to avoid claims that turn out to be false

current "truths" are supposed to be used as foundations for subsequent discoveries and learning - static and eternal truth

B. Postnormal or mission driven science

(these may be different, but are very similar for out purposes now)

problem identification from the very beginning includes multiple perspectives and values that go along with those views

most of the problems that are address are "wicked" problems (problems types)

identify questions that can be addressed:

using scientific method on a daily or experimental design level

that will help decrease the uncertainty about the system with regard to restoration or management

(see Claudia Pahl-Wostl 1998- Table for Advanced Science, science may have to describe the indeterminate factors of the problem, i.e. what we can't know or predict)

provide help choosing paths that may include using indicators of impact at a much lower level of confidence in the "truth" of the data, this goes along with the precautionary principle

may require assessing the cost-effectiveness of the proposed solutions, using tests such as safe minimum standard (see Norton 2005 pg 346)

"safe-minimum standard" (SMS) - "Save the resource, provided the costs of doing so are bearable"

employ state of the art technology and analysis, but this may increase uncertainty

(new technologies can create a large increase in uncertainty)

use a language based in science to share with a broader range of colleagues including other scientists, managers, practioners and involved citizens