Potter 1
Jill Potter
UNST121B/C
Jenks/Lewis
12/02/04
Critical Essay 2 Assignment

Society and natural desires are often times at war. In many instances, it is up to a person to decide

whether to go with society’s rulings, or to follow their own natural desires. One major struggle with this

case is whether our sex and gender are natural or socially assigned. Are we what we think we are?

Society is unwilling to accept things such as bisexuals, homosexuals, and transsexuals. Many factors

increase fear amongst ourselves, and make most of us believe that heterosexuals are the only group

that should be accepted socially.

Societal conditioning plays a huge role. From the time we are infants, we are forced to comply with

society’s rule. One example, such that a baby boy implies light blue colored things while a baby girl

implies light pink. From then the conditioning further takes place. Girls get Barbies, easy bake ovens,

and stuffed animals. Boys on the other hand get Tonka Trucks, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and combat

weapons. From the very beginning society pushes what they believe the gender should appeal to, what the

gender should get used to later on in life. Professions, hobbies, games, are all created for little kids to get

them used to society’s depiction of how each gender should act; a fine example of how society pushes our

roles as a certain gender.

It is not to say that gender cannot be naturally assigned either. There are many cases where say someone is

born a baby girl. Later in life they realize they don’t fit their gender. They have a gender identity crisis (for

lack of a more scientific term) and believe they were born into the wrong body. Is this social or natural

placement? When looked at under a certain light one can say it is natural, though society may deem it as

"unnatural" because they are going against what they were naturally assigned at to begin with. Deep down

Potter 2
someone has a mind-set that they are a different gender than they were born as. Naturally they feel they

would be more comfortable if they were something other than what they are.

To further the investigation, one must look to Coventry’s article entitled “Making the Cut: It’s a Girl...or is it?”.

The article describes the social assignment of baby boys and girls being forced to become one sex or

another at birth because of the size of their genitalia. “The strict division between female and male bodies

and behavior is our most cherished and comforting truth. Mess with that...and the ground beneath our feet

starts to tremble” (UNST121B/C Fall 2004 Packet, Coventry, Section 12, Page 55). This meaning, if a girl is born

with too large of a clitoris and a boy is born with too small of a penis, they are changed into a more

acceptable gender.

Society seems to deem males or females with smaller genitalia as the lesser of the gender. A small penis

clearly cannot be made to pleasure any woman’s needs, therefore, it is unaccepted, shunned, and

belittled. “If a boy’s penis is too small to function as a ‘real’ man’s, that boy would be better raised as a girl...

his body...altered...to look female.” (UNST121B/C Fall 2004 Packet, Coventry, Section 12, Page 56). Society’s

assignment at its finest.

The genitalia is not socially acceptable and “cannot function” as a normal one, thus it is altered to be more

acceptably fitting. This however leads to problems later in life. The body can be altered, but not the mind.

There is a natural mind-set for each sex, ans, if the girl you see before you was actually born a guy with a

small penis, she may still think like a boy, and may be confused sexually as to what she should do. Toggled

between society's depiction of what is normal and their own natural desires. The seemingly normal and the
 

                       Potter 3


 natural brains’ responses are at war in this case. Do what society tells you or go against the grain of this

suppression? “They felt deprived of choice...” (UNST121B/C Fall 2004 Packet, Coventry, Section 12, Page 59).

There are people that live with this decision because of being unwillingly genetically altered. Why should

society make these life-threatening decisions for them?

There are other forms of sexual pleasure, and it is important to know that the opposite sex does not always

have to be the one to supply that pleasure in order to remain healthy. We are naturally assigned a sexuality,

a feeling, a state of being, as well as a gender. “Females are given an organ, the clitoris, which has no other

function than sexual pleasure” (UNST121B/C Fall 2004 Packet, Stayton, Section 13, Page 2).

“If sexual pleasure is intended only for pro-creational purposes within the marriage bond, then God has

played a terrible joke on...who never married or could not have children or...have had over 30 children in

their child-bearing years!” (UNST121B/C Fall 2004 Packet, Stayton, Section 13, Page 2).  The important of this

passage is that sex is not just something to do to create a child. Sex is an emotion just like being happy or

sad. It is a way of release, a way of pleasure, something that can be done in many different ways. Sexual

pleasure is not just intercourse, but masturbation and oral, and any other type of sexual activities, and not just

used to produce offspring. Sex is a state of mind, it is a feeling, an emotion. Sex is natural, and society pushes

what they feel is natural instead of delving inside of a person.

Society views heterosexuality as the norm. Homosexuals and Transsexuals are shunned, viewed as inhumane,

viewed as being below everyone else. What society doesn’t realize is it should not matter how a person pleasures

their own being, and that one should not restrict these feelings. Society is trying to restrict nature, and that only
 

                       Potter 4


 leads to more problems later on. Restricted feelings have to come out sooner or later. We as human beings need

to open up and be more accepting of sexual implications. “Many are fearful of the implications. Maybe...

[because] of the rediscovery that the entire universe is our potential sexual orientation and we can find sexual

pleasure in all the dimensions of our life” (UNST121B/C, Fall 2004 Packet, Stayton, Page 6). The fact that society

projects so many things onto people only closes some off further. People lash out, become violent, do weird things.

Does this make them wrong? No. Society needs to have a better understanding for people. Morals, sexual

preference, gender, anything that has to do with sex tends to be limited because of society’s depictions. Sexuality

is natural, gender is natural, being human is natural. What should not be natural is popular opinion. Society should

not be expected to make decisions for people, and should not push such strong beliefs on people.

Let people think for themselves. Things should feel right for the person. They should do what they believe will make

them comfortable. Go against the grain of society. Be what you are, feel what you want to feel despite what

everyone tells you. Be selfish, take a chance and do something that makes you comfortable. In the end, this is

truly the only way to obtain pure and simple happiness.

The truth of the matter is that we are both socially and naturally assigned. It is a battle of wits with both of them,

and comes down to a person’s own choice. What is deemed appropriate and what feels comfortable to the

person are two completely different things. Though we are conditioned socially, we should follow ourselves,

follow our aspirations and our own feelings, especially those that are sexual. We need to open up, be accepting,

and do what makes us feel good. Live your life miserable being tied down to rules or open yourself up to live a

happy productive life. The choice is yours.. So think wisely!

Works Cited

Coventry, Martha. “Making the Cut: It's a Girl!...Or is it?” Forbidden Knowledge
Fall 2004 Packet. Ed. Philip Jenks. Portland: Smart Copy, 2004. 54.

Stayton, William. “A Theology of Sexual Pleasure.” Forbidden Knowledge Fall 2004
Packet. Ed. Philip Jenks. Portland: Smart Copy, 2004. 1-6.




Click here to return to the main page.Click here to see the reflection.
Website Copyright 2004.
All submitted work(s) (artwork and writing) are property of Jill Potter and shall neither be
duplicated nor copied without direct consent.
To contact please e-mail duckrodeo@hotmail.com or daytime phone (503)655-1468